In the early years, CCPA faced challenges as they searched for suitable venues to stage their productions. Productions such as "Gypsy," "Fiddler on the Roof," and "Little Shop of Horrors" found stages and audiences in various locations, including Cottey College, St. Francis Academy, Marmaduke Park, the County Fairgrounds, Nevada Middle School, and even the old state hospital. In 1984, Drs. Ted and Candace Moore offered the space behind their offices, formerly the Liberty Theater, which became the Little Alley Theater—a second home for CCPA that lasted until an unfortunate remodeling closed off their access.

Over the years, CCPA showcased a diverse array of performances, including the popular "Nunsense" series and "Steel Magnolias." They persevered through financial challenges, relying on the support of the community, patrons, sponsors, and volunteers. Their dedication to keeping the performing arts alive in Nevada has been instrumental in maintaining a historic building and providing opportunities for local talents to shine on stage.

In 1998, CCPA found a temporary home at the former First Baptist Church, christened the Red Brick Playhouse. Despite challenges like a failed air conditioning system, CCPA continued to thrive. However, it wasn't until the acquisition of the Fox Playhouse building, with support from Metz Bank and Brent Mendenhall's prize money from a game-show appearance on NBC, that CCPA found a permanent home. Renovations, including the addition of a dressing room and a Green Room, brought new life to the Fox Playhouse. CCPA's commitment to preserving and promoting the performing arts in the community has remained steadfast.